The research of Betty Li Hou, who presented a seminar as part of The New York Academy of Sciences’ Artificial Intelligence (AI) & Society Lecture series, explores the educational, philosophical, sociological, and legal dimensions that should be considered when developing ethical AI systems to benefit society.
Published November 21, 2023
By Nick Fetty
Betty Li Hou, a Ph.D. student in computer science at the New York University Courant Institute of Mathematical Sciences, presented her lecture “AI Alignment Through a Societal Lens” on November 9 at The New York Academy of Sciences.
Seminar attendees included the 2023 cohort of the Academy’s AI and Society post-doctoral fellowship program (a collaboration with Arizona State University’s School for the Future of Innovation in Society), who asked questions and engaged in a dialog throughout the talk. Hou’s hour-long presentation examined the ethical impacts that AI systems can have on societies, and how machine learning, philosophy, sociology, and law should all come together in the development of these systems.
“AI doesn’t exist independently from these other disciplines and so AI research in many ways needs to consider these dimensions, otherwise we’re only looking at one piece of the picture,” said Hou.
Hou’s research aims to capture the broader societal dynamics and issues surrounding the so-called ‘alignment problem,’ a term coined by author and researcher Brian Christian in his 2020 book of the same name. The alignment problem aims to ensure that AI systems pursue goals that match human values and interests, while trying to avoid unintended or undesirable outcomes.
Developing Ethical AI Systems
As values and interests vary across (and even within) countries and cultures, researchers are nonetheless struggling to develop ethical AI systems that transcend these differences and serve societies in a beneficial way. When there isn’t a clear guide for developing ethical AI systems, one of the key questions from Hou’s research becomes apparent: What values are implicitly/explicitly encoded in products?
“I think there are a lot of problems and risks that we need to sort through before extracting benefits from AI,” said Hou. “But I also see so many ways AI provides potential benefits, anything from helping with environmental issues to detecting harmful content online to helping businesses operate more efficiently. Even using AI for complex medical tasks like radiology.”
Social media content moderation is one area where AI algorithms have shown potential for serving society in a positive way. For example, on YouTube, 90% of videos that are reviewed are initially flagged by AI algorithms seeking to spot copyrighted material or other content that violates YouTube’s terms of service.
Hou, whose current work is also supported by a DeepMind Ph.D. Scholarship and an NSF Graduate Research Fellowship, previously served as a Hackworth Fellow at the Markkula Center for Applied Ethics as an undergraduate studying computer science and engineering at Santa Clara University. She closed her recent lecture by reemphasizing the importance of interdisciplinary research and collaboration in the development of AI systems that adequately serve society going forward.
“Computer scientists need to look beyond their field when answering certain ethical and societal issues around AI,” Hou said. “Interdisciplinary collaboration is absolutely necessary.”
Three scientists were selected from 169 entries by an international jury of renowned experts for their innovations in food security, sustainability, and healthcare. Each winner will receive INR 2 crores (approximately US$240,000) and will be honoured at a ceremony in Mumbai in December 2023. The jury included distinguished scientists, clinicians, technologists, and engineers spanning six continents from a variety of organizations, including IBM Research, Indian Institute of Science Bangalore, Indian Institute of Technology Madras, International Centre for Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology, Public Health Foundation of India, and UN-Habitat.
The 2023 Tata Transformation Prize Winners are:
Food Security Winner: Shilpi Sharma, PhD, Indian Institute of Technology Delhi Professor Shilpi Sharma was selected by the jury for her work in the engineering of the soil microbiome using synthetic microbial communities, called microBIOme-based soil TRANSFORMation (BIOTRANSFORM). Plant diseases threaten crop productivity and, consequently, the global economy. Unlike conventional farming that uses agrochemicals and synthetic fertilizers, soil amended organically has the natural ability to suppress a wide range of plant pathogens. Starting from naturally suppressive soil, Shilpi will catalog the active microbial players and their mechanism of suppression of a range of phytopathogens. Her work will be the first to map the natural suppressive potential of soil across six states of India and to harness this potential by microbiome engineering to facilitate sustainable agriculture in the country and beyond.
Sustainability Winner: Purnananda Guptasarma, PhD, Indian Institute of Science Education and Research Mohali Professor Purnananda Guptasarma was selected by the jury for his breakthrough methods to degrade polyethylene terephthalate (PET), a common plastic pollutant, using enzymes. PET is currently produced and used at unsustainable levels, creating worldwide plastic pollution and micro-plastic contamination in the air, water, and soil, as well as in animal and human bodies. Only 9% of PET is actually recycled worldwide. Guptasarma’s enzyme-driven strategy uses engineered thermostable enzymes and reactions to demonstrate that solid PET can be broken up into its smallest molecular building blocks with high yield and ultra-high purity to enable PET’s degradation and recycling into virgin plastic. Building on this proof of concept at the laboratory-scale, Guptasarma will further identify and improve enzymatic reagents and reactions for PET degradation and attempt to produce the best enzymes in quantities allowing pilot-scale PET-waste degradation and recycling.
Healthcare Winner: Anurag S. Rathore, PhD, Indian Institute of Technology Delhi Professor Anurag S. Rathore is a healthcare pioneer aiming to reduce the manufacturing cost of biotherapeutics for treating cancer and autoimmune diseases, thus enabling equal access to these top-tier, expensive treatments currently out of reach for 90% of the Indian population. Rathore has established a state-of-the-art drug manufacturing facility with continuous processing that incorporates novel methods for real-time process monitoring and control. Rathore’s innovation is projected to reduce manufacturing costs by 50-75%, making best-in-class biotherapeutics for complex diseases significantly more affordable for Indian populations in need and further advancing India’s position at the forefront of global medical innovation.
N. Chandrasekaran, Chairman of the Board of Tata Sons, said, “We are extremely delighted to announce the first cohort of Tata Transformation Prize winners and their groundbreaking innovations aimed at solving India’s national problems in the areas of food security, sustainability, and healthcare. On behalf of Tata Sons, we are pleased to provide these scientists a global stage to take their technologies from India to the rest of the world.”
Nicholas Dirks, President and CEO of The New York Academy of Sciences, said, “Congratulations to the first Winners of the 2023 Tata Transformation Prize. From developing new soil enhancements to improve crop yield, creating methods to make critical medicines available to all, and developing techniques to tackle plastic pollution, these scientists are making important contributions to Indian society and the world. We also thank the jury for sharing their time and expertise in reviewing the submissions in the first year of the Tata Transformation Prize.”
About the Tata Transformative Prize
The Tata Transformation Prize was established in 2022 by Tata Sons and The New York Academy of Sciences to support breakthrough, innovative technologies that address India’s most significant challenges. By recognizing and supporting the implementation at scale of high-risk, high-reward research, the Prize will drive impactful innovation in scientific disciplines of importance to India’s societal needs and economic competitiveness. The Prize will leverage the exceptional potential of scientists in India to address critical national challenges in three categories—Food Security, Sustainability, and Healthcare—and generate improved life quality outcomes across India and beyond. The Tata Transformation Prize recognizes one Winner in each category, with INR 2 crores (approximately US$240,000) for each Winner. Click here for more information about the Tata Transformation Prize.
About the Tata Group
Founded by Jamsetji Tata in 1868, the Tata Group is a global enterprise, headquartered in India, comprising 30 companies across ten verticals. The group operates in more than 100 countries across six continents, with a mission ‘To improve the quality of life of the communities we serve globally, through long-term stakeholder value creation based on Leadership with Trust’.
Tata Sons is the principal investment holding company and promoter of Tata companies. Sixty-six percent of the equity share capital of Tata Sons is held by philanthropic trusts, which support education, health, livelihood generation and art and culture.
In 2022-23, the revenue of Tata companies, taken together, was $150 billion (INR 12 trillion). These companies collectively employ over 1 million people. Each Tata company or enterprise operates independently under the guidance and supervision of its own board of directors. There are 29 publicly listed Tata enterprises with a combined market capitalisation of $300 billion (INR 24 trillion) as on July 31, 2023. Companies include Tata Consultancy Services, Tata Motors, Tata Steel, Tata Chemicals, Tata Consumer Products, Titan, Tata Capital, Tata Power, Tata Communications, Indian Hotels, Tata Digital, Air India and Tata Electronics. Website: https://www.tata.com
The Tata Transformation Prize is the latest in a series of prominent awards and scholarship programs The New York Academy of Sciences and its partners present each year to accomplished early-career and established scientists worldwide. These initiatives, along with education and professional development programs for students and young scientists, reflect the Academy’s broader commitment to strengthening and diversifying the pipeline for skilled and talented scientists globally. Please visit us online at nyas.org.
Developing targeted therapies for rare cardiomyopathies is challenging: difficulties identifying patients, delivering therapeutics, and accessing heart tissue results in a 50% mortality rate 5 years after diagnosis. Early, accurate disease detection and classification can significantly improve outcomes for patients with rare cardiomyopathies. Achieving these goals requires multiple novel technologies to coalesce that will enable early patient identification, deepen our understanding of the disease process, improve modeling of human pathophysiology, accelerate testing of drug candidates, and leverage novel therapeutic modalities to target the heart specifically, safely and effectively.
This two-day conference will convene industry scientists, academics, and clinicians to understand the integration of artificial intelligence and engineered tissues for safe and effective delivery of novel therapeutics for patients with arrhythmogenic, hypertrophic, and dilated cardiomyopathies.
In this special edition of Science Unusual, we bring you the International Science Reserve’s session from the Science Summit at the 2023 United Nations General Assembly.
In collaboration with the Academy, the Windreich Department of Artificial Intelligence and Human Health at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, is organizing the second annual symposium: “The New Wave of AI in Healthcare 2024.” This event aims to showcase the latest advancements in AI- and data-driven technologies in healthcare. The symposium will feature keynote and plenary lectures by industry leaders, as well as poster presentations from early career investigators and students, highlighting the latest innovations in the field. Additionally, it will provide networking opportunities for researchers across disciplines and sectors to collaborate and advance their work. The venue, located in New York City, is designed to facilitate dialogue and collaboration, driving progress in the field of healthcare AI.
Rapidly evolving digital technologies are changing modern healthcare in unprecedented ways. Novel digital health solutions are embracing machine learning and artificial intelligence (AI) tools that empower patients and healthcare providers alike. However, given the speed of innovation, it can be challenging to stay abreast of the latest technological advances.
To showcase the latest advances in AI- and data-driven technologies in healthcare, the Windreich Department of Artificial Intelligence and Human Health at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai and the New York Academy of Sciences will convene multi-disciplinary scientists and clinicians working at the intersection of computer science and medicine for a 2-day, in-person symposium in New York City entitled “The New Wave of AI in Healthcare”.
This symposium will feature a keynote presentation by David C. Rhew, MD, Global Chief Medical Office and Vice President of Healthcare at Microsoft. In addition, leaders in the field will present plenary lectures, and there will be poster presentations by early career investigators, students, and postdocs. The New Wave of AI in Healthcare will provide a forum for the exchange of novel scientific research and expertise among multi-sector scientists and provide ample networking opportunities.
The AI & Society Fellowship was developed to address the unmet need for scholars who are trained across technical AI and social sciences and the humanities.
Launched by The New York Academy of Sciences and Arizona State University in April 2023, the fellowship was developed to address the unmet need for scholars who are trained across technical AI and social sciences and the humanities. This innovative training program will produce the next generation of scholars and public figures who are prepared to shape the future use of AI in ways that will advance the public good.
The Fellows are:
Nitin Verma, PhD, University of Texas at Austin, School of Information
Nitin studies the ethical, societal, and legal impacts of deepfakes and other generative AI technologies. His multidisciplinary research interests include misinformation, trust, human values, and human-computer interaction. He is a native of India, and attended the University of Delhi, graduating with a B.Sc. in electronic science.
Akuadasuo Ezenyilimba, PhD, Arizona State University (ASU), The Polytechnic School; Human Systems Engineering
As a National Science Foundation Research Trainee, Akuadasuo has worked on citizen-centered solutions for real-world problems. Currently, she is researching the relationship between human-computer interaction and traumatic brain injury, executive function, and traumatic brain injury rehabilitation.
Marjorie Xie, PhD, Columbia University Medical Center, Center for Theoretical Neuroscience
Marjorie’s work combines AI, mental health, and education. She interned at Basis Research Institute, building AI tools for reasoning about collaborative intelligence in animals. Marjorie completed her Ph.D. in Neurobiology & Behavior at Columbia University, where she used AI tools to build interpretable models of neural systems in the brain.
Developing the Next Generation of AI Researchers
“AI now permeates every facet of our society,” said Nicholas Dirks, Ph.D., President and CEO, The New York Academy of Sciences. “The technology holds extraordinary promise. It is crucial that researchers have the training and capacity to bring an ethical perspective to its application, to ensure it is used for the betterment of society. That’s why our with partnership with Arizona State University, where much of the pioneering research in AI and society is being conducted, is so imperative.”
“ASU is very excited to join with The New York Academy of Sciences for this fellowship,” said David Guston, professor and founding director of ASU’s School for the Future of Innovation in Society, with which the post-docs will be affiliated. “Our goal is to create a powerhouse of trainees, mentors, ideas, and resources to develop the next generation of AI researchers poised to produce ethical, humanistic AI applications and promote these emerging technologies for the public interest” he added.
Beginning in August 2023, the promising young researchers will participate in a curated research program and professional development training at the Academy’s headquarters in New York City, Arizona State University, and on-site internships, with seasoned researchers from academia, industry, or public policy organizations.
About Arizona State University
Arizona State University, ranked the No. 1 “Most Innovative School” in the nation by U.S. News & World Report for eight years in succession, has forged the model for a New American University by operating on the principles that learning is a personal and original journey for each student; that they thrive on experience and that the process of discovery cannot be bound by traditional academic disciplines. Through innovation and a commitment to accessibility, ASU has drawn pioneering researchers to its faculty even as it expands opportunities for qualified students.
As an extension of its commitment to assuming fundamental responsibility for the economic, social, cultural and overall health of the communities it serves, ASU established the Julie Ann Wrigley Global Futures Laboratory, the world’s first comprehensive laboratory dedicated to the empowerment of our planet and its inhabitants so that all may thrive. It is designed to address the complex social, economic and scientific challenges spawned by the current and future threats from the degradation of our world’s systems.
This platform lays the foundation to anticipate and respond to existing and emerging challenges and use innovation to purposefully shape and inform our future. It includes the College of Global Futures, home to four pioneering schools including the School for the Future of Innovation in Society that is dedicated to changing the world through responsible innovation. For more information, visit globalfutures.asu.edu.
The Blavatnik Awards for Young Scientists seek to identify and honor exceptional young scientists and engineers 42 years of age and younger. Honorees are selected based on the quality, novelty, and impact of their research and their potential for further significant contributions to science. For previous issues of awardee papers, see Ann NY Acad Sci (2012) 1260 and Ann NY Acad Sci (2013) 1293. Or click https://nyaspubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/toc/10.1111/(ISSN)1749-6632.blavatnik-awards.
In the healthcare field, artificial intelligence has the potential to improve everything from workflow efficiency to patient outcomes.
Published May 25, 2023
By Stephen Treffinger
Image Credit: Agne Sopyte Members of the Organizing Committee. (From left to right) Affiliated with the Mount Sinai Health System: Christina Virgo, Esq., Sara Roncero-Menendez, Silke Muehlstedt, PhD, Thomas Fuchs, Dr. sc., Marc Kaplan; Affiliated with The New York Academy of Sciences: Melanie Brickman Borchard, PhD, MSc, Barbara Knappmeyer, PhD
Appearing on the front page of news outlets nearly every day, artificial intelligence (AI) is already transforming the world. And it’s doing so at a staggering pace. In the healthcare field, it has the potential to improve everything from workflow efficiency to patient outcomes. But sifting through the hype can be a tremendous challenge.
The Windreich Department of Artificial Intelligence and Human Health at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai and the New York Academy of Sciences hosted the ‘New Wave of AI in Healthcare’ symposium as a “call to action.” This brought together experts and leaders across the field to tackle this challenge through innovation, exchange, and collaboration.
The symposium took place over the course of two days: May 23 and 24, 2023. Researchers, academics, and industry leaders presented and discussed innovative research. They also focused on clinical solutions with the potential to advance the capabilities of AI. The goal is to better serve patients and clinicians from diagnostics to long-term care.
Opening remarks were delivered by, Nicholas Dirks, President and CEO of The New York Academy of Sciences, and Dr. Dennis Charney, Dean of the Icahn School of Medicine and President for Academic Affairs for the Mount Sinai Health System. They challenged attendees to identify ways to utilize the enormous amounts of health data available. If utilized properly, this can help predict, prevent, and develop more robust treatments for disease.
Advancing the Capabilities of AI
The two-day symposium featured sessions on foundational models that revolutionize diagnostics processes, infrastructural challenges to facilitate large-scale models and innovative deep learning solutions to deal with the petabytes of data generated in healthcare. Also, the symposium addressed ethical considerations for AI research in healthcare to eliminate bias and ensure its application is equitable as well as impactful.
“Today, patients are dying not because of AI, but because of the lack of it,” stated Thomas J. Fuchs, Dr. Sc, Dean for AI and Human Health at Mount Sinai, lead member of the scientific organizing committee in opening the symposium, Dr. Fuchs further emphasized that although machine learning has already led to significant achievements across the field of healthcare, we are only at the beginning of an AI revolution in healthcare.
Image Credit: Monika Graff (From left to right) Panelists: Eric Lium, PhD, Mount Sinai Health System, Brandon D. Gallas, PhD, U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Emma Benn, DrPH, Mount Sinai Health System, Moderator: Eric Nestler, MD, PhD, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai
AI Fundamentals – Facts, Fictions, and Possibilities
Despite the immense hype around AI (as Dr. Fuchs remarked, “If you haven’t talked about ChatGPT, you’re probably living under a rock.”) and excitement in the start-up scene (including 14,000 healthcare startups in the AI realm), the reality is not quite as dramatic. There are only a few AI applications that practitioners currently use in the clinical setting to benefit patients. “While the FDA cleared hundreds of systems in radiology, in pathology, for example, there’s one single system that has proven to be safe and effective.”
Dr. Fuchs stated that AI gives us the possibility to truly democratize access to healthcare for the first time in history. “The AI we’re developing here and you’re developing at your fabulous institutions can be used in community clinics throughout the U.S. and throughout the world.”
A Deep Crisis in Healthcare
The fact that clinicians are burned out and leaving practices has, according to several of the speakers, resulted in a deep crisis in healthcare. But AI is able to help combat this trend by automating workflows. One of the keynote speakers at the symposium was David C. Rhew, MD, Global Chief Medical Officer and VP of Healthcare at Microsoft. He presented developments in Ambient Clinical Intelligence. This system can, among other things, capture clinician-patient conversations and bring the information into the medical record.
“We have an ability now to pull data about individuals from every aspect. We can look at the perspective of what EHR [Electronic Health Record] data we have, what genomics data we have, and real-time data collection through remote monitoring.” This creates a 360-degree view of a person and one that changes as they evolve. “Now imagine having that at a population level,” he says. “That’s where the real power comes.”
Image Credit: Monika Graff (From left to right) Dennis S. Charney, MD, Anne and Joel Ehrenkranz Dean of the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, President for Academic Affairs, Mount Sinai Health System Nicholas B. Dirks, PhD, President and Chief Executive Officer, The New York Academy of Sciences Thomas J. Fuchs, Dr.sc., Co-Director of the Hasso Plattner Institute for Digital Health at Mount Sinai, Dean of Artificial Intelligence and Human Health, and Professor of Computational Pathology and Computer Science at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai
AI for Healthcare and Life Sciences – Accelerated Discovery
Will more data and data-driven models yield better patient outcomes? This was a central theme throughout the symposium. Speakers utilizing foundational models in research and clinical diagnostic support tools to create deep learning models. Researchers develop these across heterogenous data modalities to improve patient outcomes.
The conference’s second keynote was delivered by Jianying Hu, PhD, from IBM Research. Dr. Hu is also an adjunct professor at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai. In addition to IBM’s use of AI to drive accelerated discovery, she discussed what it means to go beyond large language models to apply foundational models to healthcare and life sciences research.
“In our view, [it’s] really all about enabling the journey from data to impact. AI can be used to help with the development of new molecular entities through novel generative methods, as well as computational screening tools [that] can be used to also identify new indications for drugs that are already approved,” says Dr. Hu. In addition to drug repurposing, AI is critical, she says, for being able to identify multimodal biomarkers.
From the Laboratory to Practice: Clinical Applications of AI
Moving from the theoretical to the practical and harnessing the full power of AI will require a change in approach, especially as it pertains to data: how much of it is required, how it needs to be treated, and how to maximize its effects. Abundant medical data is playing an important role, as precision medicine tries to determine the right treatment for the right patient at the right time.
“When we think about precision medicine and AI in medicine, we think about the health state of a patient and how we can model that health state of a patient,” says Gunnar Rätsch, PhD, ETH Zürich, who is currently conducting research as a visiting scientist within Mount Sinai’s AI Department.
Evidence of the health state comes from heterogeneous data modalities such as EHRs, pathology images, genomic profiles, drugs, and mobile health data. Integrating this data into computational representation enables practitioners to access a patient’s health state. This requires new advances in AI approaches to exploit the specifics in the medical data, which requires genuine partnership between clinicians and machine learning/AI researchers.
Image Credit: Yovanna A. Roa, LMSW Christina Virgo, Esq., Director of Operations Hasso Plattner Institute for Digital Health at Mount Sinai
The Impact of the New Era of Large-scale Deep Learning Models
Increasing the speed by which researchers can process and analyze vast amounts of data is an ongoing challenge in AI. The exponential growth of healthcare data, genomics, electronic records, and imaging can overload systems and slow the path to progress.
But processing capacity and speed aren’t the only issues. Another challenge is to better merge clinical medicine and data science, the two being mutually beneficial. Anthony Chang, MD, from the Children’s Hospital of Orange County, thinks this is an essential—albeit largely absent—duality. Few people understand both sides of the equation.
Dr. Chang also sees the need for a shift to a new paradigm of databases, i.e. graph databases. “These are more three-dimensional and much more accommodating of the complexities of healthcare data. […] I can’t imagine we’re going to get a lot more dividends using deep learning healthcare without a change in how we look at databases, which is relational databases.”
In the detection of breast cancer, to cite one example, having very large scan sizes is advantageous, but dealing with these enormous images efficiently can be problematic due to the amount of memory in the GPU and other factors. Krysztof J. Geras, PhD, NYU Langone Health, discussed the particulars of multiple instance learning. “We have this ability to indicate those parts of the image that are important. We can actually look at this image with greater detail with a higher capacity network, but just at a certain region of it, and then we can fuse this information. And that works amazingly well.”
AI at Mount Sinai
The Mount Sinai Health System is dedicated to leading an AI-driven transformation of healthcare. This is done through innovative research, pioneering clinical care, and personalization for each patient. The aim is to have a wide-reaching impact on human health. In 2021, Mount Sinai established the Windreich Department of Artificial Intelligence and Human Health. This is the first department focused on AI and Human Health in any medical school in the United States.
As a leader in the AI in healthcare space, researchers at Mount Sinai are building an “intelligent fabric” of AI that will underpin all interdisciplinary efforts. They are combining AI, computer science, machine learning, and data science across the Health System to support every individual who comes through the hospital doors for care. It will also support nurses, physicians, scientists, hospital operations and leadership,
Several Mount Sinai researchers presented their AI-integrated research during the symposium. They highlighted the various ways in which this new technology can benefit researchers, clinicians, and patients. This ranges from diagnosis to treatment, as they are developing some of the most exciting advances in the field.
Highlights include:
Ipek Ensari, PhD, who works with AI and machine learning combined with statistics in the field of women’s health, noted the possible link between indicators in the female reproductive system to diseases such as coronary artery disease, and stroke.
Hayit Greenspan, PhD, focuses on AI in the medical imaging space. “We are developing a platform that provides tools for collection of the data, support of annotation of the data, and support of modeling that can be done to extract information that is useful from the imagery data.”
Xiaosi Gu, PhD, focuses on the fast-growing sub-sector of mental health in health tech. “We need to both achieve a mechanistic understanding of the brain and of the mind at the algorithmic level and to use brain-related data to try to create predictive models.”
John F. Crary, MD-PhD, is a neuropathologist and runs a research lab in neurodegenerative diseases. “Alzheimer’s is a monumental public health crisis. It’s really important […] to get […] tissues digitized, organized, and made available to scientists and computational people.”
Bruce J. Darrow, MD-PhD, who leads Mount Sinai’s AI ethics committee, often works on creating spaces and treatments that are not only safe and effective, but also equitable, being tested across the right demographics and taking into account factors such as insurance coverage, income, and zip code.
Robert Freeman, RN, MSN, NE-BC, is working on moving from the reactive to the predictive and preventative AI. In practice, this would lead to shorter patient time in the hospital and improved overall 30-day mortality.
Image Credit: Monika Graff (From left to right) Thomas J. Fuchs, Dr.sc., Mount Sinai Health System, Keynote Speakers: Jianying Hu, PhD, IBM Fellow, Director, HCLS Research, Global Science Leader, AI for Healthcare at IBM Research, David Rhew, MD, Global Chief Medical Officer, Vice-President of Healthcare, Microsoft
Governance and Ethics for the Use of Large Healthcare Datasets for AI
The use of massive amounts of patient data for AI naturally raises key governance and ethics issues. This includes data privacy, transparency, regulatory compliance, and bias screening to ensure fair representation. These issues and more were covered in a panel discussion moderated by Dean Eric Nestler, MD, PhD, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai.
The role of bias in large healthcare data models can take many forms. This is especially thru when it comes to populations of color and members of underrepresented communities. One of the panelists, Emma Benn, DrPH, is a biostatistician at Mount Sinai, applies her training to health equity research. She addressed the governance and ethics of the topic. In terms of race, she posed the question of whether the algorithms and technology are just describing racial and ethnic differences versus being able to operationalize race in a way that gets closer to identifying mutable targets for intervention.
“If we’re not operationalizing things correctly, we’re not going to be able to use AI to reduce health inequalities,” says Benn.
The Importance of Data Privacy
Another panelist, Dr. Erik Lium, PhD, discussed the importance of data privacy. Dr. Lium is the Chief Commercial Innovation Officer for the Mount Sinai Health System and the President of Mount Sinai Innovation Partners. One question posed by the audience was which processes a hospital uses to protect a patient’s personal health data. The answer depends on who is going to use said data, be it internally for research or with an external partner. Internally, an institutional review board decides acceptable usage. For use with external partners, it involves legal agreements with copious protections. These protections bar anyone from taking, for instance, de-identified data and attempting to re-identify the data.
“You can use the data for a stated purpose that we think is ultimately beneficial to patients. If you go outside of that purpose, then you’re doing something that’s inappropriate,” says Dr. Lium.
Keynote speaker Dr. David Rhew ended his address on a key philosophical and ethics-focused note. He brought up the idea of AI taking a pause to prevent potentially harmful aspects like the spreading of misinformation. “If the good actors pause on this, that doesn’t mean that the bad actors are going to pause.”
In Conclusion
Throughout the symposium, speakers were able to address successes, challenges, and future initiatives. This is needed to further the development of new AI technology in the field and how it can be implemented to better patient outcomes. Some of the key takeaways from the symposium’s sessions include:
Increasing cooperation between institutions.
Figuring out how to obtain and efficiently process ever larger data sets.
Using AI to enhance patient experience and outcomes.
Finally, these developments will need to be carefully and continuously filtered through the lenses of equitability and security to ensure that every patient receives the highest level of care no matter the setting. The ‘New Wave of AI in Healthcare’ symposium was an important step towards this equitable, AI-integrated future, with more advancements and discussions to come.
Merging technical AI research with the social sciences and humanities, the program aims to inform the future use of AI for the benefit of humankind.
In response to the urgent need to incorporate ethical and humanistic principles into the development and application of artificial intelligence (AI), The New York Academy of Sciences has partnered with Arizona State University’s School for the Future of Innovation in Society to launch an AI and Society post-doctoral fellowship program. Merging technical AI research with perspectives from the social sciences and humanities, the program’s goal is to develop a new generation of multidisciplinary scholars prepared to inform the future use of AI in society for the benefit of humankind.
“The New York Academy of Sciences is thrilled to launch this unique partnership with Arizona State University, where much of the pioneering research in this field is being conducted,” said Nicholas B. Dirks, President and CEO of The New York Academy of Sciences. “AI is transforming our society at lightning speed. It is essential, however, that we work to better understand the range and nature of AI’s impact and what we can do to anticipate, and then navigate, the many ethical, regulatory, and governance questions that we have only recently begun to comprehend and debate, even as we press forward with leveraging AI’s benefits,” he added.
“ASU is very excited to join with The New York Academy of Sciences for this fellowship,” said David Guston, professor and founding director of the School for the Future of Innovation in Society. “Our goal is to create a powerhouse of trainees, mentors, ideas, and resources to develop the next generation of AI researchers poised to produce ethical, humanistic AI applications to promote science for the greater good” he added.
Recruiting Promising Young Researchers
Beginning in September 2023, this program will recruit promising young researchers from disciplines spanning computer science, the social sciences, and the humanities to participate in a curated research program housed at the Academy. Fellows’ time will be shared between New York City, Arizona State University, and on-site internships, with seasoned researchers who are well-versed in academia, industry, or policy work.
To qualify, candidates must have a PhD in a relevant field such as computer science, artificial intelligence, psychology, philosophy, sociology, ethics, law (JD), or a related field. Strong research background and expertise in the field of AI and Society, including publications in leading academic journals, is recommended.